Historical Fiction’s Use of Emotional Connection
The retelling of history requires a large number of facts and documented events which are meant to be shared in a way that can be retained and spread. For example, American nonfiction is typically expressed and learned through textbooks that simply provide details and explanations of causes and effects. On the contrary to the more informative, direct mode of historical nonfiction, historical fiction employs various styles in order to get its message across to the reader. This message includes lessons, various stories, and most importantly, the experiences of those who lived during that time. Books and historical works such as Wandering Stars, The Buddha in the Attic, Hamilton, and Homegoing have all involved techniques that succeeded in engaging with the reader. Historical fiction utilizes a wide array of writing style and structure, a very immersive and detailed description of the setting, and storytelling from the perspective of one person, to connect emotionally with the reader and deepen their understanding of history as a lived experience.
By using a distinctive structural approach to convey historical facts, these historical fiction stories are able to keep the reader engaged by encouraging a stronger interest in learning about the past. One example of an unconventional way of storytelling is found in The Buddha in the Attic, which narrates from the perspective of an entire community. “On the boat, we often wondered: Would we like them? Would we love them? Would we recognize them from their pictures when we first saw them on the dock?” (Otsuka 4). This quote shows how Otsuka uses “we” to represent the entire community of Japanese picture brides to demonstrate how widespread their treatment was. This helps the reader understand the shared hopes, fears, and questions that almost all of these women have, making their historical presence more significant. Otsuka’s unique way of structuring the novel, which is repeated throughout, emphasizes that history is something that is experienced, and not just recorded. Another, arguably more revolutionary way of structuring a historical narrative is presented by the musical Hamilton. This work uses energetic songs to capture the audience’s attention and strong emotions through acting. “I am not throwin' away my shot / Ayo, I'm just like my country / I'm young, scrappy and hungry / And I'm not throwin' away my shot” and “No one really knows how the game is played / We just assume that it happens / But no one else is in the room where it happens”. (Miranda, My Shot, The Room Where It Happens). Hamilton uses many different musical styles to structure the story, matching the mood and pacing of events which further allowed the audience to easily follow the history. Through these songs, the audience learns not only how the revolutionary era was experienced, but the significance of each event. This intentional variation in style turns a complex combination of historical events into a comprehensible story, which keeps the audience paying attention while learning the order and importance of history. Although The Buddha in the Attic uses repetitive language and Hamilton does the exact opposite, constantly changing the pacing of the performance, they both use distinctive narrative methods to facilitate understanding a large amount of historical detail. Overall, various modes of structuring and presenting historical information not only help the reader better understand the information, but it also hooks the reader into wanting to continue learning more about the history.
American history is filled with thousands of stories and events, however, many people have had shared experiences. Detailed portrayals of the setting in which individuals or communities experience history allow readers to visualize what the characters endure and emotionally understand the realities of those shared experiences. A detailed description of a character’s setting is consistently repeated in the book Wandering Stars. In almost every part of the story, with each new character, comes a setting entirely new to the narrative. For example, in both Jude Star and Opal Viola’s cases, Tommy Orange narrates, “There was something there, as big as a mountain…it did look like my people were getting chewed up by those hundreds of bullets fired” (Orange 18) and “Here at the creek, a ways off from the trail, we have black berries for now, not as fat and sweet as they get…when you pull at them and leave your fingers stained” (Orange 79). Similarly, Yaa Gyasi narrates the story with depth in her settings to visualize the rough conditions of plantation life. Ness is described as, “She worked all day like this, listening to the sounds of the South. The insistent buzz of mosquitoes, that screech of cicadas, the hum of slave gossip” (Gyasi 75) and “A man cradling his own body curled up against the wall on a dirty mattress. Two women readying themselves for the needle a second man was holding.” (Gyasi 256) By listing qualities of a Southern plantation, Gyasi places the reader right into Ness’s environment, with her working constantly. In Sonny’s world, the cramped drug room helps the reader understand the tough decision that he will have to make under undesired circumstances. Writing historical fiction allows authors to use their imagination when creating a setting for their characters. Although the setting has to be somewhat realistic, they are able to add as much detail as needed, to make the reader feel as if they are there with the character. These detailed settings help readers visualize the challenges, experiences, and even triumphs of the characters, making these distant historical events seem closer and more relatable. By immersing the reader in the environment, the author doesn’t just show what happened, but deepens their emotional and historical understanding. Both stories envision the character in harsh scenarios, using hopelessness and an inescapable setting as a way to make the reader feel the same way the character feels. These settings can have a significant impact on the reader’s understanding of a story, but that effect also depends on the author’s narrative structure and the perspective through which the story is told.
Finally, by typically telling the story through the lens of a person rather than a larger community, historical fiction seeks to keep the reader emotionally attached to the character and the impact of circumstances on people. Both Tommy Orange and Yaa Gyasi take advantage of this necessary part of historical fiction to help the reader understand the trauma and suffering that each of their characters has to endure. Charles Star’s struggle in Wandering Stars is a prime example of telling a story through one person, where he begins to reflect on how he feels before he dies. “She would be better off without him, is the thought he has before a darkness gathers in his periphery, leading him away from the pain he’d been running from for too long” (Orange 65). By focusing on just one character at a time, the book emphasizes every emotion that character is feeling. In this scene, the reader is most likely sympathetic with Charles Star, despite him having just robbed a store, and might begin to understand the experience of Charles and many other Native Americans during that time. Individual focus turns very broad historical issues into a specific example of someone living through it, which teaches the reader the significance and impact of the time period. A similarly personal lens is used by Gyasi in Homegoing, that clearly demonstrates the factors of systemic injustice that may not have been as effectively expressed if told through nonfiction. Homegoing pairs a unique structure of storytelling—one that follows an ancestry line into modern day—with personal perspectives that visit numerous settings and historical movements shaped by the current political standing of the post-Civil War South. In the chapter discussing H’s life, Gyasi brings the reader on a ride through H’s time being convicted, sold, and freed from working in a coal mine, as shown. “‘Don’t matter if you was or wasn’t. All they gotta do is say you was.’... H was chained to ten other men and sold by the state of Alabama…He thought about going back home, but realized that he didn’t know where home was. There was nothing left for him on the old plantations he’d worked, and he had no family to speak of.” (Gyasi 158-159/166). Through H’s perspective, the history held in textbooks isn’t just the term “systemic injustice” anymore, but is a collection of lives that have suffered over and over again. The reader can easily interpret H’s emotion and involvement in this system, and use it to create their own well-informed opinions and thoughts on this topic. Furthermore, this narrative choice of referencing existing people, rather than just presenting facts, allows the reader to engage and understand H’s experiences and the injustices that he and many others went through. It also highlights that this painful life is not isolated, but is part of a continuing historical pattern. One can argue that Charles Star and H’s experiences served to draw the audience closer to history, by sharing sentimental and possibly vulnerable emotions felt by the characters. By exemplifying historical events in individual experience, historical fiction modifies distant historical patterns and circumstances and turns them into realities that readers can remember and grasp.
Historical fiction narratives often use a blend of these strategies to relate to the reader emotionally. As a result, they can creatively explain historical details in ways that a traditional textbook cannot. In Hamilton, readers are presented with a mix of a unique structural approach and the telling of stories through the perspectives of characters such as Hamilton, Washington, and Jefferson. The fast paced musical structure and shifting genres combined with the passionate monologues of each character mirror the urgency of the Revolutionary era and the impacts of many events during that time. Similarly, The Buddha in the Attic merged an unconventional storytelling method with limited depictions of settings to have the reader understand the prevalence of Japanese oppression. The “we” perspective builds on Otsuka’s choice to rarely describe the setting and makes the reader feel as if they are jumping from person to person, encapsulating the idea that Japanese struggles were widespread. Finally, both Homegoing and Wandering Stars include very descriptive settings that pair with personal perspectives that make the reader feel empathy for the characters. Additionally, they feel as if they are witnessing history through those that experience it. Overall, these methods are essential to writing a historical fiction novel because they can be used in many different forms, and in many cases, hand in hand to develop the story. Nonfiction historical texts cannot achieve this, as their primary purpose is to present high-detail factual information about events, excluding emotion, bias, and most other subjective elements of storytelling. On the other hand, pure fiction cannot achieve what historical fiction can because fiction allows the readers to make assumptions or theories based on their own knowledge, preventing the realization that the stories told actually happened. In the end, it is this ability to humanize historical events through emotion and perspective that allows historical fiction to leave a more lasting impression on readers.
Ultimately, historical fiction novels possess the ability to migrate from conventional nonfiction teaching, to an illustration of descriptive lived experiences of real people. By using a unique structure that hooks the reader and makes them want to learn more, describing the setting vividly to bring the reader closer to the text and the subject matter, and telling the story through the perspectives of individual characters shaped by their current situations, they transform learning history into something meaningful and engaging. These aspects of historical fiction writing work together to coherently teach history and humanize the past in ways that nonfiction cannot. Most importantly, historical fiction has the power to reshape meaning, turning impersonal terms into something tangible that readers can emotionally connect to and learn from. In doing so, it ensures that the past is not only understood but is able to be retold and passed down to future generations.
***In this essay, I used AI for my revisions to help me achieve my goal of connecting the three topics I wanted to focus on: structure, setting, and personal narrative. It helped me understand how to make that connection and how to properly address and reference points that I had talked about in previous paragraphs. It also helped me realize the importance of providing a deeper analysis with my chosen pieces of evidence, by highlighting the fact that simply summarizing and arguing that these tactics alone can effectively complete the author’s goal was not sufficient. I needed to clearly explain how each example works with each other and how they connect back to my claim. Through this process, I understood the difference between summary and analysis in my writing, and was able to strengthen both. Overall, using AI as a tool to improve my work was insightful, as I aligned my use with the idea that AI is impersonal from the article, and limited myself to only using AI’s tips on connecting ideas and improving clarity.



Comments