top of page
Search

More Than Merit Badges

Oct 7
4 min read

The bugle’s call of reveille rolled across the camp, brushing through the pine trees and bouncing off canvas tents before finally dragging everyone awake. Within minutes, boys stumble out of tents in wrinkled uniforms and unlaced boots, trying to look alert while half asleep. They place their stiff-rimmed hats on their heads before lining up single file to march to breakfast. Then, they take on a five mile trek through rocky paths, stumbling over tree roots, and mud-caked socks. Stopping to identify new plants they find, to mimic bird calls, or to lecture everyone about Leave No Trace principles, the campers truly demonstrate their love for the outdoors. After a long, treacherous excursion, they finally reach the peak of whatever grand mountain they chose to climb this time. Planting one foot onto a rock and pulling the antique telescope out of their bag, they scan the horizon, with dramatic seriousness and contemplation. These well-behaved, wilderness-loving and overly prepared Boy Scouts of America are a product of their strict, boisterous adult leaders, and the values of saving lives and being of service. They are awkward kids collecting as many merit badges as possible, marching around campsites with “Scout’s Honor” following every statement, obsessed with tying knots and lashes, and selling popcorn door to door in rehearsed voices. Or at least, this is what people think they are.

As a Cub Scout, Boy Scouts seemed to be an organization of nerdy kids who would carry around enough supplies to survive a nuclear fallout. As a Cub, scouting was simple. The once-a-month meetings were fun, filled with games, and rarely with knots, lashings, or first aid. The highlight of this time in scouting was when the firemen came to our summer day camp during the summer and sprayed water over us, saving us from the dry heat. We cared more about pinewood derby races than learning leadership or responsibility.

Yet, no matter how dorky I thought the scouts were, the transition to Boy Scouts was daunting. No longer were there fellow companions of elementary school age, but there were high schoolers who seemed to know it all. They lashed catapults faster than I could imagine and tied knots even faster. They didn’t shy away from teaching the younger scouts a new skill or correcting someone when they did something unsafely. They carried themselves with confidence, experience, and an interest in exploration. On campouts, they gave reminders to not leave food in tents, to keep the patrol boxes organized, and to clean up even the smallest scraps of trash imaginable. However, the assumptions that I, along with many others, held that made Boy Scouts seem like a joke quickly began to disappear. The kids I expected to be obsessed with rules and badges were the same people who stayed after meetings to clean up, who had meaningful conversations with the adults to improve the troop, and who made friendships with scouts old and young. These people were scouts for the life-lessons learned through various experiences, not to learn order, obedience, and compliance. They learned responsibility and applied it. Their roles in the troop ranged from simply being a member of a patrol, to organizing the vast collection of gear the troop owned. The Scouts were also experts, knowing how to explain skills and keep everyone involved while dealing with troublesome younger scouts. A scout stood still in the pouring rain, steady and relaxed. He looked around, and calmly gave directions to the frantic, less experienced scouts, setting up camp as fast as possible as tents popped up and fell down around him. Leadership was not loud authority, it was making sure things actually got done. If one member of the troop failed, it affected everyone, since they had to stay organized or the troop would fall behind. Missing a meeting, skipping an email, or forgetting to plan an event only created more work for everyone else. Because of this, communication and preparation was essential. They prepared for campouts, checked for broken or missing supplies, and made backup plans without being told when they had misplanned. They worked to identify problems, not just solve them. 

Most importantly, they had fun. The senior patrol would always reenact the same skit they had been for the last five years during campfires. One night, four of us crowded into a small tent, pressed against half-unrolled sleeping bags and seas of backpacks. The dying flashlight let us see just enough to read the numbers on the cards, so we could whisper the occasional “UNO!” while the other scouts were sleeping. We were building friendships and memories, through the stifled laughs and the rustling of sleeping bags throughout the night. A Scout troop functions because the scouts trust each other, depend on each other, and enjoy being around each other, participating for the experience rather than for the patches sewn onto their uniforms. They are not the brainwashed, rigid, soldier-like people portrayed in many books and movies, but dependable and eager to take on challenges to make a positive impact on their troop and the world.

 
 
 

Comments


Learn Immune created and conceptualized by MIlan T Shah, all rights reserved. 2026

bottom of page